I would have to say that all the above is true, and as Tug said, knowing what kind of driving you do will be the best way to recommend a tire.
If you do alot of highway on an everyday commute, you might want to get an All-terrain instead of a Mud Terrain. The tread pattern is closer together and will be alot less prone to cupping (uneven wear). I had a set of the BF Goodrich AT/KO's on my YJ and put over 100 miles a day on them. They were excellent in every catagory except deep mud, which they were decent, but certainly no mud terrain. I have also owned Dunlop Radial Rover RV (a little less money than the BFG AT). They were very good tires as well, wearing and performing well.
If you drive it daily but not alot of highway, I would go with a mud terrain. Which one depends on your budget. All the above recommendations are sound.
If you're planning on using them mainly on a trail, get a set of Super Swamper TSL Radials. They're the old standby and will sling the mud like no other.